Some musings on conflict
Aug. 14th, 2021 08:46 pmThinking about the need to earn certain types of emotion in writing . . .
I have just today picked up some scraps of a story I started almost four years ago and then abandoned because I had no real reason for the source of the conflict. I think I've thought of a reason now, and an emotional payoff the story can have, and I've been filling in other bits of the story (and in doing so, of course, transforming those first bits I wrote so long ago). But that payoff is so important, and in order to have it, it needs to be earned - and I'm concerned about my skill level in the ability to earn it.
I feel this way about a lot of fic that uses miscommunication as a main device. Part of it is that I'm personally not a big fan of miscommunication in general, always screaming "just TALK to each other!" at characters and overcompensating in my own work in which characters talk far too much. But I think it's also that it's so easy for miscommunication to go wrong. Sometimes I see characters not sharing things with one another, or expressing things wrong, and it's not frustrating in that particular way miscommunication can be frustrating, but frustrating because it doesn't make sense for who they are or the situation they're in. It feels too forced as conflict, and then the payoff, when it comes, feels cheap and unsatisfying because I couldn't get behind the reason for the miscommunication in the first place.
Now, I'm in the situation of needing a significant obstacle for these characters - an obstacle significant enough for one of them to commit what the other perceives as a betrayal of their friendship. I have a vague conception of what the obstacle is, but I'm so concerned with making it appropriately weighty, the stakes feel appropriately high - because otherwise, that betrayal feels purposeless, the conflict is unearned, and the eventual coming-together feels cheap. And I have this idea in mind, but now I have to be sure to express it in such a way that all that comes through. As I said to a friend earlier, I want people to be mad at me, but I want to deserve their anger. And I can only hope my skill level is up to the task.
I have just today picked up some scraps of a story I started almost four years ago and then abandoned because I had no real reason for the source of the conflict. I think I've thought of a reason now, and an emotional payoff the story can have, and I've been filling in other bits of the story (and in doing so, of course, transforming those first bits I wrote so long ago). But that payoff is so important, and in order to have it, it needs to be earned - and I'm concerned about my skill level in the ability to earn it.
I feel this way about a lot of fic that uses miscommunication as a main device. Part of it is that I'm personally not a big fan of miscommunication in general, always screaming "just TALK to each other!" at characters and overcompensating in my own work in which characters talk far too much. But I think it's also that it's so easy for miscommunication to go wrong. Sometimes I see characters not sharing things with one another, or expressing things wrong, and it's not frustrating in that particular way miscommunication can be frustrating, but frustrating because it doesn't make sense for who they are or the situation they're in. It feels too forced as conflict, and then the payoff, when it comes, feels cheap and unsatisfying because I couldn't get behind the reason for the miscommunication in the first place.
Now, I'm in the situation of needing a significant obstacle for these characters - an obstacle significant enough for one of them to commit what the other perceives as a betrayal of their friendship. I have a vague conception of what the obstacle is, but I'm so concerned with making it appropriately weighty, the stakes feel appropriately high - because otherwise, that betrayal feels purposeless, the conflict is unearned, and the eventual coming-together feels cheap. And I have this idea in mind, but now I have to be sure to express it in such a way that all that comes through. As I said to a friend earlier, I want people to be mad at me, but I want to deserve their anger. And I can only hope my skill level is up to the task.